For Sandra, the cost of energy bills means sometimes restricting her heating to a single room and relying on a small portable electric heater. Without her Personal Independence Payment benefits, she would be “forced to choose between heating or food". While Sandra’s heating system is in good condition, issues with how it was set up have led to it not running as efficiently as it could, and a lack of clear guidance means she is using it highly inefficiently by repeatedly boosting the heat rather than letting it run continuously.
Sandra is one of the social housing tenants we interviewed as part of our work looking at the quality of heat pump installations in social housing. Her reality highlights the distinct challenge of decarbonising the UK’s 4.1 million social homes. While heat pumps are a proven, highly-efficient and reliable technology, their success in helping people in fuel poverty relies heavily on high quality system design, installation, commissioning and operation.
To understand how these systems are performing on the ground, Nesta partnered with Bristol City Council to conduct and analyse 92 technical heat pump audits and 37 tenant interviews. We learned five critical lessons about closing the gap between expected performance and the lived reality of social tenants, which we are working on with Bristol and others to implement.
Heat pumps are a robust and reliable technology, but, as with any heating technology, achieving high real-world performance relies on an interconnected chain of good practices. Across the 92 technical audits analysed, design, installation and commissioning faults were common, ranging from degraded pipe lagging to missing design calculations and disabled weather compensation.
Crucially, these underperformance issues stem from gaps in quality assurance, procurement, installation and handover procedures rather than failures of the heat pump technology itself. When designed, installed and commissioned correctly, heat pumps reach the high efficiencies needed to deliver steady warmth and can undercut legacy heating systems on running costs.
Our interviews identified a paradox: some tenants were highly satisfied with their heat pumps even when the systems were technically underperforming and running inefficiently.
This disparity was because their satisfaction was heavily dictated by expectations set by their previous heating setups. Tenants who transitioned from expensive, inefficient electric storage heaters viewed their heat pump as a major upgrade in baseline comfort and affordability, regardless of how well the new unit was actually running. On the other hand, some tenants expressed frustration with their heating despite having some of the highest-performing heat pumps we audited. Often used to the quick, intense blasts of gas boilers, these residents struggled to adapt to the steady, lower flow temperature of the system. This indicates that social housing providers cannot rely on tenant feedback or complaints alone to identify which systems are underperforming.
Addressing technical underperformance does not necessarily require replacing entire heating units. Follow-up repair visits to 30 of the audited homes tested whether low-cost, pragmatic fixes, such as replacing missing external lagging, lowering flow temperatures, and re-enabling weather compensation, could improve system setups.
These targeted visits cost an average of £204 per household, with 94% of the cost representing labour. While time constraints meant we were unable to quantitatively verify long-term performance changes post repair, early feedback from follow-up interviews indicated positive signals, with some tenants observing improved hot water delivery and lower running costs. Further research is needed to measure these impacts over full heating seasons.
Inadequate handover processes mean many tenants receive no practical guidance on how to run their systems efficiently. Many of the residents who inherited their heat pump when moving into a property received little to no handover at all. Those who were briefed were often overwhelmed with information, with residents typically handed dense, overly technical manufacturer manuals, instead of clear quick-start guides.
Without an intuitive understanding of the technology, anxious tenants fall back on energy rationing behaviours. To save money, many use their heat pumps like traditional boilers, turning them on for short, intense blasts or switching the power off entirely. This stop-start approach prevents the heat pump from running continuously at a steady temperature, driving up costs. To empower residents, social housing providers must move away from single handover touch points toward repeated engagement, during initial installation, ahead of the winter heating season, during servicing visit and whenever a new tenant moves in.
On-site installation and commissioning faults are frequently symptoms of upstream procurement challenges and internal skills gaps. To prevent performance issues before contractors even step on site, social landlords should shift away from a traditional 'fit and forget' approach to contracting and begin procuring with clear, performance-based outcomes.
Social housing providers can take a proactive approach to quality control. They can achieve this by embedding real-world performance metrics into contracts, requiring heat loss calculations prior to sign-off, and upskilling internal asset management teams to secure long-term value for tenants.
For tenants like Sandra, this combination of targeted repairs and clear, tailored advice can make a tangible difference. A few months after receiving adjustments to her system, she reported a noticeable improvement in her understanding of how it operates. Having previously boosted the heat in short, costly bursts, she now plans to let it run continuously through the winter, taking back control of both her comfort and her bills.
To find out more about the quality of heat pump installations in social housing and how to improve outcomes for residents, download our full research report and practical Action Guide.