More than one in three adults in Wales are living with obesity, higher than any other nation in the UK. The economic and social costs are staggering, estimated at £5.2 billion each year, including around £470 million in NHS costs.
Making meaningful progress on obesity in Wales requires a shift in approach, focusing on changing our food environments to make it easier to eat healthily, rather than expecting individuals to overcome an environment that encourages unhealthy choices.
The healthy food standard, a policy inspired by Nesta, could help achieve this by introducing mandatory reporting and targets to improve the healthiness of large food businesses' sales. Our modelling suggests it could reduce adult obesity in Wales by around 17%, with substantial benefits for children's health and the economy too.
But ensuring people across Wales benefit will require action from the Welsh Government.
The healthy food standard involves two key elements:
Mandatory reporting is the critical step needed to gauge the healthiness of what is sold, track progress, but alone would have a negligible impact on obesity. Mandatory targets are therefore essential to driving meaningful change, particularly given how voluntary industry targets have delivered limited progress. To ensure these targets are actually effective, Nesta recommends giving regulators the power to issue financial penalties to businesses that fail to comply.
We recommend that both mandatory reporting and targets are based on a sales-weighted nutrient profile model (NPM) score. This is the measure of healthiness already used by governments across the UK to determine which foods are subject to restrictions on price promotions and placement, and advertising of foods high in fat, salt or sugar (HFSS). It provides a holistic assessment of nutritional quality, considering both less healthy nutrients, such as sugar and salt, and beneficial components, such as fibre and fruit and vegetables. Weighting by sales reflects what customers actually buy, rather than simply what retailers stock.
Unlike existing HFSS regulations, which classify foods as healthy or unhealthy using a fixed threshold, Nesta recommends that health targets are set as a continuous NPM score. This would incentivise improvements across retailers' entire product ranges, rather than focusing only on products close to the threshold, resulting in positive shifts across a wider selection of products.
Nesta recommends initially focusing the healthy food standard on the largest supermarkets, which account for around 80% of calories purchased across Great Britain and already have much of the data needed to comply. To maintain a level playing field, governments should also look to introduce targets for the out-of-home (OOH) sector, while noting that the OOH sector has further to go to improve their data. Here are five things to know about what the healthy food standard could mean for Wales.
The healthy food standard was proposed by the UK government, but because health policy is devolved this does not mean the policy would automatically apply in Wales.
There are two ways people in Wales could feel the benefit of the healthy food standard. The Welsh Government could use its devolved powers to introduce legislation through the Senedd specifically for Wales, for a potentially different version of the same basic policy. Alternatively the Senedd could consent to the UK Parliament legislating for Wales.
We recommend the second approach, enabling a coordinated UK-wide approach. This aligns with Welsh Government principles for when UK-wide legislation may be appropriate in devolved areas, including where shared arrangements make a common approach more effective. Most major supermarkets operate across national borders, while bodies such as the Food Standards Agency already work across England and Wales. Nesta analysis also found that the healthiness of retailers' sales is similar in Wales and across Great Britain, supporting the case for a common target. Together, these factors strengthen the case for introducing the healthy food standard consistently across the UK.
The healthy food standard is all about shifting incentives for businesses so they make the healthier option the easier option for everyone - rather than banning specific foods, or telling people to choose carrots over crisps. The policy would give businesses flexibility to meet their targets in ways that work for their customers and business model. This could include adjusting pricing and promotions, reformulating products or making healthier products more prominent.
Polling shows strong public support for this approach, with 70% of people in Wales supporting targets to increase sales of healthier food.
Nesta's modelling suggests mandatory health targets for major supermarkets could reduce adult obesity in Wales by around 17%, with a similarly substantial reduction expected in childhood obesity. These improvements could generate around £880 million in annual social and economic benefits for Wales. This includes around £80 million in NHS savings, equivalent to around 40% of NHS Wales’ £199 million deficit in 2025–26.
With the potential to considerably reduce obesity and deliver wider societal benefits at little cost to the public purse, the healthy food standard would be a uniquely cost-effective approach to tackling obesity in Wales.
The 11 largest supermarkets account for around 90% of calories purchased for consumption at home in Wales, a similar proportion to the rest of Great Britain. This extensive reach is a key reason why mandatory targets for supermarkets could be the most effective lever for improving diets on a wide scale.
Importantly, this extends across different communities - in Wales, supermarkets account for more than 90% of calories purchased for eating at home across income groups and in both rural and urban communities. This matters for health inequalities. Rates of obesity are higher in more deprived communities in Wales, while lower-income households tend to purchase less healthy food. These households could therefore have the most to gain from healthier supermarket sales, as the improvements wouldn’t rely on extra time, money or effort.
One potential concern is that retailers could meet their targets by concentrating improvements only in more affluent areas, while neglecting poorer communities. However, Nesta tested this scenario and found that even if supermarkets exceeded the recommended target in the most affluent 20% of areas, while leaving sales elsewhere unchanged, no retailer would meet its overall target. This suggests retailers would need to improve the healthiness of their sales across different communities, rather than focusing only on more affluent customers to hit the target.
Careful monitoring will also be important for evaluating the impact across Wales. Requiring retailers to report detailed data on the healthiness of their sales across different communities would help governments track how benefits are distributed and respond where needed.
Independent economic analysis commissioned by Nesta suggests the healthy food standard is unlikely to increase household food bills, partly because strong supermarket competition makes it unlikely supermarkets will pass on additional costs to consumers. Separate Nesta modelling suggests relatively small changes to a typical shopping basket for lower-income households could deliver substantial reductions in calorie consumption without increasing cost.
Nesta estimates that implementation costs would average less than 0.006% of major retailers' combined annual turnover of around £210 billion, spread over five years. The policy would focus on large companies, rather than small or medium-sized businesses. Large supermarket chains already collect sales data and, because they operate across the UK, much of the cost of implementing the policy would be incurred centrally rather than separately in Wales.
The healthy food standard offers Wales an opportunity to substantially reduce obesity while placing relatively little pressure on public finances. But realising these benefits will require action from the Welsh Government.
Encouragingly, Mabon ap Gwynfor MS, now Minister for Health and Social Care, spoke positively about mandatory health targets for major food retailers during a Senedd debate in January 2026, when he was Plaid Cymru’s health spokesperson. He highlighted their potential to improve food environments and reduce obesity.
However, more than 500 days after the UK Government announced the healthy food standard, the consultation originally promised for spring 2026 has still not been published. We urge the Welsh Government to work with the UK Government to ensure Wales is included in the planned consultation, and to press for its publication without further delay, with a view to introducing a consistent UK-wide policy.
If progress at UK level continues to stall, the Welsh Government should consider introducing its own legislation to ensure people in Wales do not miss out on the policy's potential health and economic benefits.
It's also important that Welsh voices make the case for mandatory targets alongside reporting. Reporting alone would increase transparency, but without targets the policy is unlikely to deliver meaningful improvements to diets.
We encourage organisations and stakeholders across Wales to respond when the consultation launches, make their voices heard and help shape a policy that will transform health outcomes in Wales for the better.