About Nesta

Nesta is a research and innovation foundation. We apply our deep expertise in applied methods to design, test and scale solutions to some of the biggest challenges of our time, working across the innovation lifecycle.

Turning heat pump audit results into better results for tenants

The reality on the ground

Transitioning Bristol’s social homes away from polluting fossil fuels is a critical step in reducing our city’s carbon emissions. Heating currently makes up around 40% of our energy-related emissions. But deploying clean technology is not just about cutting carbon. It’s about delivering steady, affordable warmth to residents, many of whom are vulnerable to fuel poverty.

While heat pumps are a robust, reliable and highly efficient technology, achieving high real-world performance relies on them being installed, commissioned and used well. Bristol City Council partnered with Nesta to understand how these systems are actually performing on the ground. The recently published report highlights that quality assurance, installation and handover issues often prevent these systems from working at their best. 

Nesta assessed 92 heat pump installations and interviewed 37 residents across Bristol to understand their lived reality. The research revealed that common faults, ranging from degraded pipe lagging to disabled weather compensation, were preventing these systems from running efficiently and driving up running costs. Furthermore, the research highlighted that inadequate handovers left residents anxious and confused, leading them to use their heat pumps in very inefficient ways. Discussions we’ve had with colleagues from other local authorities and housing providers have confirmed that many of these issues are found in other parts of the country.

Crucially, we learned that these underperformance issues stem from gaps in procurement, quality assurance, and handover procedures, rather than failures of the heat pump technology itself. Far from being discouraging, this was a reassuring finding. Because these challenges are operational rather than technological, they are entirely within our control as service commissioners, meaning social landlords do not need to wait for central government policy shifts to make a difference. Recognising that every social provider has the power to fix these upstream processes, we brought together teams across the council to form a dedicated heat pump working group. Here is how Bristol City Council is turning those insights into proactive, practical action on the ground. 

Taking action: moving from findings to solutions

To address the root causes identified in the research, we have overhauled how we procure, install, and manage our heating systems.

1. Shifting to outcome-based procurement

The audits showed that standard industry compliance doesn't always guarantee real-world efficiency. In response, we designed a new performance-based specification. Building on standard MCS requirements, we introduced more stringent benchmarks that directly impact residents' bills, such as setting minimum design performance targets, and requiring post-install monitoring alongside auditing of all installations. This empowers our teams to set clear expectations from day one.

2. Moving beyond 'one-and-done' handovers 

The research found that poor handovers left some people overwhelmed by dense technical manuals. To rebuild tenant confidence, we collaborated with the Centre for Sustainable Energy to completely reshape our handover procedures. We are rolling out more accessible support materials and exploring innovative approaches, such as video-recording handovers to help jog residents' memories. We also now mandate that installers check back in with tenants post-installation to ensure the system is delivering comfortable heat.

3. Closing the skills gap with higher-level training

A recurring challenge in scaling successful deployments is finding high-quality installers. To combat this, we have mandated higher-level training requirements for any contractors wishing to work with us.

Because housing officers also need to know what a good installation looks like, we designed and delivered specialised heat pump training for our internal staff, ensuring our delivery teams can spot technical red flags early. This training helped officers understand our new quality assurance processes and how to follow the steps within this. 

4. Embedding rigorous quality assurance

To ensure accountability, auditing is now firmly embedded into our delivery programme. We developed a new quality assurance framework that mandates a light-touch self-audit completed by the installer on-site, followed by an independent third-party audit. This places a much stronger focus on actual performance assessment. We also found that the audit provided another opportunity to give residents a recap on how to use their system, which has built knowledge among the home users. 

5. Unlocking performance data through remote monitoring

Hidden performance data prevents landlords from addressing underperforming systems. We believe that remote assistance is critical for managing heat pumps cost-effectively at scale. We recently delivered a remote monitoring trial to help us understand and navigate the practical challenges of this technology. Monitoring is mandated as default on all installations.

Conclusion: Scaling success for the future

While the findings of the Nesta research highlight gaps in installation quality and tenant support, the broader message for the social housing sector is fundamentally optimistic. Heat pumps are a proven, robust and highly efficient technology. When quality is assured and installations are accompanied by clear guidance and support, they hold immense potential not only to decarbonise our housing stock, but to directly tackle fuel poverty by delivering steady, affordable warmth.

Bristol City Council’s commitment extends far beyond our own city limits. We recognise that decarbonising social housing is a national challenge that requires shared learning and outcome-based solutions. We are dedicated to influencing broader industry standards. To ensure these insights reach the practitioners who need them most, we completed a roadshow tour reaching over 300 professionals to share best practices, and we have helped create a dedicated LinkedIn group with the Carbon Trust to foster ongoing industry dialogue.

To learn more about the research that informed our approach, as well as more details for what social landlords can do to improve outcomes, you can read the full Nesta report and action guide.

Author

Matthew Jones

Matthew Jones is a UK trained surgical doctor with international field experience.