About Nesta

Nesta is a research and innovation foundation. We apply our deep expertise in applied methods to design, test and scale solutions to some of the biggest challenges of our time, working across the innovation lifecycle.

Simple changes could reduce workload for food industry applying updated food and drink healthiness model, Nesta says

  • Nesta tested how hard it is to work out the sugar content in 11,000 supermarket products using the government’s updated health scoring system - the nutrient profile model.
  • It found simpler rules for determining “free sugars” would make the job of implementing the government’s proposed changes easier and leave most scores unchanged.

London, UK - New analysis published today looking at how much work it takes for food businesses to calculate “free sugars” in supermarket products finds that just two potential simplifications could make this simpler for industry to carry out for almost 3 in 4 products.

The research and innovation foundation Nesta examined free sugar content in more than 11,000 products, using only the information printed on the back of the product’s pack. Free sugars are sugars added to food and drink, plus those released when fruit and vegetables are broken down, such as juiced or puréed. The UK government scores foods and drinks on how healthy they are using a system called the nutrient profiling model (NPM). It is already used to decide which products face limits on advertising and promotion.

The model’s 2018 update scores free sugars, not total sugars. The government launched a public consultation on applying this updated NPM model - referred to as "new NPM" - to existing restrictions on "less healthy" (High in Fat, Salt, and Sugar, or HFSS) food and drink advertising and promotions. The new NPM model would require industry to calculate “free sugars”. Free sugars aren’t declared on food and drink labels and can’t be looked up, so businesses have to calculate them from ingredient information that is often hard to get. Industry has said this is a barrier to putting the updated model into practice.

Nesta’s analysis found:

  • Following the decision trees in government’s current technical guidance, almost 3 in 4 (73%) of products would need detailed ingredient-level data to calculate free sugars
  • Much of that effort makes little difference to the immediate regulatory outcome - among products covered by current advertising and promotion rules, scores were uncertain enough to affect their “healthier” or “less healthy” status for only around 500 products - just 4% of our total dataset. So, only a minority were close enough to the line that the uncertainty could change whether they count as “healthier” or “less healthy” under current advertising rules
  • Fewer than 1% of products moved between “healthier” and “less healthy” under any assumption tested

In Nesta’s analysis, most products kept the same NPM score. The products where calculation is hardest, such as soups and ready meals, contribute little to the free sugar people eat. The ten most complex categories together account for less than 5% of children’s free sugars intake.

While this suggests that it will be difficult but possible for industry to implement the new NPM model for HFSS regulations, Nesta is highlighting that implementing the new NPM model should not hold up the government moving forward with a policy with more potential to reduce obesity - the healthy food standard. The healthy food standard policy was announced by the Secretary of State for Health as part of the government’s 10 Year Plan for Health in June 2025, and will require food retailers to report on and work to targets for the healthiness of their sales. Nesta modelling suggests it could help around 3 million people achieve a healthier weight but the NPM would likely need to be used for measuring healthiness of sales under the policy.

Annie Denny, director of healthy life at Nesta, said: “Implementing the changes required for the updated nutrient profile model is no easy task for industry, but our analysis does suggest it is possible. Crucially, in our analysis, only around one in twenty-five products was hard to classify as ‘healthier’ or ‘less healthy’ and a couple of simple changes to government's technical guidance could cut the work involved. There should be a path forward for government and industry to work together on pragmatic solutions to simplify free sugars calculation.

“Everyone involved wants the same thing - for healthier food to be the easier option. The healthy food standard, which would level the field and bring in mandatory healthiness reporting and targets for supermarkets, is how we get there. The free sugars work is important, but it needn’t slow this down, so we’d encourage everyone to keep moving on the healthy food standard alongside it.”

Ends

Notes to editors

  1. The report, Finding the sweet spot: a faster, pragmatic route to free sugars implementation, is available on 18 November 2026.
  2. The analysis covers about 11,000 UK supermarket food and drink products collected in July 2026. Nesta used a variety of techniques and tools, including AI tools - such as for classifying how processed fruit and vegetable ingredients are - to analyse the data. The outputs were checked against human expert judgement and non-AI approaches. The data preparation and statistical modelling were reviewed by nutritionists and an independent Bayesian modelling expert.
  3. The analysis uses one retailer’s portfolio and label data, so figures for individual products are estimates, not audits, and results may differ for other businesses. Nesta has provided a summary of the technical method and results in the report. Further details will be published in a technical report at a later date. Decisions on technical guidance sit with DHSC and ministers and the guidance on decision trees is as per the October 2026 DHSC guidance.
  4. For more information on the analysis or to speak to one of the experts involved, please contact Anja McLoughlin, Group Media Manager, on 020 7438 2576 or [email protected] . Spokespeople are available for broadcast interviews.
Part of
Press